Review: 1917 (2019)

A Riveting and Visually Stunning War Epic

Sam Mendes’ 1917 (2019) is a breathtaking cinematic experience that immerses viewers into the harrowing realities of World War I. Shot in what appears to be a continuous, single take, 1917 stands out not only for its technical mastery but also for its emotional intensity. With a simple yet effective story, Mendes delivers a war film that is as much about the human condition as it is about the horrors of battle.

Plot Overview

Set during the First World War, 1917 follows two young British soldiers, Lance Corporals Schofield (George MacKay) and Blake (Dean-Charles Chapman), who are tasked with a seemingly impossible mission: to deliver a message to another battalion to stop them from walking into a deadly German trap. The film takes place in real-time, with the audience accompanying the soldiers on their perilous journey across the war-torn landscape. With German forces in close proximity and time running out, Schofield and Blake must traverse dangerous terrain, navigate the chaos of the battlefield, and face personal challenges to complete their mission.

The Good: A Cinematic Masterpiece, Stunning Technical Execution, and Strong Performances

1. The One-Take Shot Technique
One of the most impressive features of 1917 is its cinematography. The film is presented as if it is shot in one continuous take, a technique that immerses the viewer in the journey of the soldiers. Cinematographer Roger Deakins, who won an Academy Award for his work, crafts each scene with precision and grace. The seamless transitions between moments of intense action and quieter, more reflective beats give the film a sense of urgency while maintaining a reflective, humanistic core. This approach makes 1917 feel like an experience rather than just a movie, putting viewers right alongside the characters as they navigate the horrors of war.

2. Emotional Depth Amidst the Chaos
While 1917 is filled with tense, action-packed sequences, it doesn’t lose sight of the emotional journey at the heart of the story. The bond between Schofield and Blake is central to the film’s emotional weight. Despite the minimal dialogue, the performances of MacKay and Chapman bring out the humanity in their characters, and viewers are emotionally invested in their survival and the success of their mission. The film beautifully conveys the exhaustion, fear, and courage that the soldiers experience, making their struggle against both time and the brutal environment all the more poignant.

3. Stunning Cinematography and Visuals
As mentioned, Roger Deakins’ cinematography is one of the film’s standout features. The use of long, sweeping shots and the seamless transitions between scenes create a visual experience that is both awe-inspiring and immersive. The depiction of the war-torn landscapes—ranging from barren fields to haunting, destroyed towns—adds a layer of realism to the film. The lighting, particularly in the nighttime sequences, evokes a sense of dread and despair, heightening the tension as Schofield and Blake face one obstacle after another.

4. Sound Design and Score
The sound design of 1917 is another standout feature. The film’s soundscape enhances the immersive experience, from the distant rumbles of artillery to the sudden, jarring sounds of explosions. Thomas Newman’s score subtly complements the action, building in intensity during key moments while allowing the atmosphere to speak for itself. The music, paired with the sound design, elevates the emotional depth of the film.

The Weaknesses: A Simple Plot and Limited Character Development

1. Predictable Storyline
While 1917 excels in its technical execution and emotional impact, its story is relatively simple and straightforward. The narrative of two soldiers on a dangerous mission, while engaging, doesn’t break new ground in terms of war storytelling. There are moments of suspense and emotional stakes, but the overall plot is not particularly surprising or complex. As a result, the focus is placed more on the experience of the journey than on the intricacies of the plot.

2. Limited Character Development
Given the real-time nature of the film and its focus on the journey, character development takes a backseat. Schofield and Blake are both compelling characters, but their backstories and personal motivations are only hinted at rather than explored in depth. This is understandable given the format of the film, but some viewers may feel that they didn’t fully connect with the characters beyond their roles as soldiers on a mission.

Themes and Messages

1917 explores themes of duty, sacrifice, and the futility of war. The film examines how soldiers must carry out orders without fully understanding the consequences of their actions, highlighting the sense of inevitability that pervades warfare. The relationship between Schofield and Blake reflects themes of friendship and loyalty, with the two soldiers depending on each other for survival in an unforgiving world. The film also touches on the idea of individual heroism within the larger machine of war, as the soldiers must rise to the occasion despite the overwhelming odds stacked against them.

Standout Moments

• The Crossing of No Man’s Land
  One of the most nerve-wracking moments in the film occurs when Schofield and Blake must cross No Man’s Land, the deadly, barren area between opposing trenches. The tension is palpable as they carefully navigate the wreckage, and the sudden danger that arises adds to the scene’s intensity. The cinematography and sound design during this sequence are masterful, creating a feeling of dread that permeates the entire scene.
• The Nighttime Village Sequence
  Another memorable moment occurs when Schofield seeks refuge in a French village. The film shifts from intense action to a hauntingly quiet atmosphere, allowing viewers to reflect on the cost of war. The eerie stillness of the village contrasts sharply with the chaos of the battlefield, underscoring the pervasive sense of destruction and loss that war brings.

Final Thoughts

1917 is a war film that transcends the genre, offering a visual spectacle, emotional depth, and a powerful portrayal of the human cost of war. While its plot may be simple and its character development limited, the film’s immersive cinematography, strong performances, and technical achievements make it a must-see. Sam Mendes has crafted a film that is as much about the journey as it is about the destination, and the experience of watching 1917 is one that will stay with you long after the credits roll.

Rating: 9/10

A stunning and immersive war epic, 1917 delivers both emotional depth and thrilling action, creating an unforgettable cinematic experience.